In comp.os.linux.advocacy, Tim Smith
<reply_in_group@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote
on Wed, 16 Apr 2008 17:44:41 -0700
<reply_in_group-A49B60.17444116042008@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>:
> In article <crgid5-6qh.ln1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
> The Ghost In The Machine <ewill@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>> >> I don't like Seagate. They are claimed to have reliable
>> >> hard drives, but the two externals that I have from
>> >> Seagate 'disconnect' sometimes (incomplete Linux support),
>> >> which is a problem if you run backup scripts as cron jobs.
>> >
>> > And of course it's not a Linux problem.
>>
>> This is indeed a Linux driver problem. Presumably someone
>> is going to have to look into it and ascertain precisely why
>> Seagate external units disconnect from the main computer.
>
> I'd hold back on that conclusion until more information is available.
> In particular, do other drives work fine on that system?
Do other OSes work fine on that system as well?
>
> I had the same symptoms. I tried other brand drives, and even thumb
> drives, and the problem persisted. That's because it wasn't the drives,
> or the drivers. The USB ports on my motherboard went flaky. So I
> tossed in a cheap ($10 or so) USB card, moved my drives over to that,
> and everything has lived happily ever after.
>
So in your case it's a hardware problem. Interesting,
and logical enough. Of course the OP didn't make that
very clear in his post.
Of course one would hope for a printk() at least when
the USB flakes out, in the Linux case. Ideally, it would
then try to reconnect, though with flaky power good luck
on that.
--
#191, ewill3@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
/dev/signature: Resource temporarily unavailable
--
Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com
|
|