Outcome of controversial XML format war depends on Asia
,----[ Quote ]
| The Redmond, Seattle-based software giant, is leaving no stone unturned to
| ensure OOXML gets the extra few votes it needs at the ISO’s ballot resolution
| meeting in Geneva end-February. ISO members then have a month to change their
| votes, if they so wish.
|
| Last month, Microsoft invited the international press for a media briefing in
| Seattle to give its take on the OOXML debate.
`----
http://www.theedgedaily.com/cms/content.jsp?id=com.tms.cms.article.Article_11616beb-cb73c03a-19214b10-dd9f0caa
And then came the brainwash and disinformation.
Betanews insights: OOXML patent concerns
,----[ Quote ]
| It was pointed out before that the OSP has an unclear scope, is not
| sub-licensable (=probably GPL incompatible) and is of questionable validity
| in legal systems of nations other than the United States. Microsoft does
| everything it can to contribute to market confidence...
`----
http://www.noooxml.org/forum/t-41475/betanews-insights:ooxml-patent-concerns
...Microsoft press release as a new article, despite the fact that it repeats
old and /inaccurate/ news. More propaganda for the Vole.
Microsoft adds OOXML to its promise not to sue
,----[ Quote ]
| In another carefully timed move to garner support for its document format
| still under consideration for an international standard, Microsoft today
| altered the terms under which use of its Office Open XML format by developers
| is permitted.
`----
http://www.betanews.com/article/Microsoft_adds_OOXML_to_its_promise_not_to_sue/1203096360
Related:
Developers warned over OOXML patent risk
,----[ Quote ]
| "Smaller players and non-IT firms--those who are not and perhaps cannot be in
| close business deals with Microsoft--are potentially at a disadvantage in not
| having either a relevant competing patent portfolio to bring to negotiations,
| or the legal resources to assess the level of risk," Vaile said. "This is why
| a truly global open standard ideally needs to be dealt with in a way that
| removes obvious sources of uncertainty for smaller participants as well."
`----
http://www.zdnetasia.com/news/software/0,39044164,62037862,00.htm
Microsoft patents by Brian Jones
,----[ Quote ]
| For fun we just did a quick search of published US patent applications
| with "Brian Jones" as an author, and "Microsoft" as the assignee.
|
| [...]
|
| Some of these, like the packing ones, seem to apply directly to OOXML. What
| isn't clear to us is why Microsoft would pursue patent protection for patents
| rights that their are promising that they won't assert over users of OOXML.
`----
http://www.noooxml.org/forum/t-35323/microsoft-patents-by-brian-jones
Wishful Spinning
,----[ Quote ]
| OOXML gets adopted. More and more projects are started. Let's see which of
| these would survive without funding. Meanwhile a spin factory sends out
| success stories that most bloggers find worthless to discuss. It is possible
| to get the Krauts on board that are supposed to review OOXML but would OOXML
| survive a review by the crowds?
`----
http://www.noooxml.org/forum/t-35292/wishful-spinning
Digging in the Comments: Patents
,----[ Quote ]
| Patent licensing is probably the most important aspect for all third parties
| that want to implement or use the Open XML specification. Unfortunately the
| Ballot Resolution Meeting cannot discuss these aspects because only technical
| and editorial issues would get resolved.
|
| [...]
|
| When you have a patent which covers Open XML and you refuse to license it,
| the standard process gets stalled. Large companies in the standardization
| process are reluctant to use that nuke option. Given the ambush that the
| software patent practice means today it is quite possible that Open XML
| infringes a patent and all parties eventually have an obligation to license
| it.
`----
http://www.noooxml.org/forum/t-31491/digging-in-the-comments:patents
Patent threat looms large over OOXML
,----[ Quote ]
| "If OOXML goes through as an ISO standard, the IT industry, government and
| business will encumbered with a 6000-page specification peppered with
| potential patent liabilities" said NZOSS President Don Christie.
|
| "Patent threats have already been used to spread doubt amongst organisations
| keen to take advantage of the benefits of open source. No one knows whether
| such claims have any merit, but it is calculated to deter the development and
| use of open and alternative toolsets."
`----
http://nzoss.org.nz/node/179
Cyberlaw OOXML Seminar 14 December
,----[ Quote ]
| However, this raises the issue - what assurance does a developer have that
| such a large specification is not the subject of third party patent claims?
| ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
| The pedigree of the specification is certainly no reason for hope, Microsoft
| has been the target of third party patent claims for some time now including
| some high profile losses in patent suits. The fact that the specification has
| been developed behind closed doors and on a fast track means that there has
| been no adequate opportunity to evaluate the likelihood of third party patent
| claims against the specifications. The sheer size of the document suggests
| there will be at least a couple hiding in there somewhere.
`----
http://brendanscott.wordpress.com/2007/12/13/cyberlaw-ooxml-seminar-14-december/
ISO warned about possible patent violations of DIS29500 (aka OOXML)
,----[ Quote ]
| I have just send the following email to ISO members (you can find some of
| their email addresses on the INCTIS website) to warn them about the possible
| patent ambush...
`----
http://jeremywang67.blogspot.com/2008/01/iso-warned-about-possible-patent.html
|
|
